Short answer: Rent guarantee insurance is bought by the landlord and normally pays only if the tenant passed referencing. A professional guarantor is paid for by the tenant and lets you accept applicants who would otherwise fail. Choose insurance for tenants who reference well; choose a professional guarantor for those who don’t; and check how each product handles damage and eviction costs.
Why the choice matters more in 2026
With Section 21 gone and rent in advance capped at one month in England, possession for arrears now runs through the courts and takes longer. A landlord’s exposure to a non-paying tenant is larger, and the old fallback of taking six months upfront has gone.
Side by side
| Rent guarantee insurance | Professional guarantor | |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays | Landlord | Tenant |
| Typical cost | About 2.5–5% of annual rent | Depends on the tenant’s circumstances |
| Tenant must pass referencing | Usually yes | No; it exists for tenants who don’t |
| Covers damage | Rarely | Often (Centurion: 10 weeks’ rent) |
| Legal and eviction costs | Usually a legal expenses limit | Varies (Centurion handles the process) |
| Can start mid-tenancy | Sometimes, with conditions | Normally set up at the start |
When rent guarantee insurance makes sense
Your tenant has a clean reference, a stable income and you mainly want the rent covered while you regain possession. It’s a predictable annual cost.
When a professional guarantor makes sense
Your best applicant is self-employed, a student, newly arrived in the UK, on Universal Credit or has an old CCJ. Without a guarantor you’d turn them down; with one, the tenant pays for the cover and you can let the property sooner, with less void time.
Using Centurion for either
- Protecting Landlords (paid by the landlord, monthly or annually) covers up to 24 months’ rent from the date of default, 10 weeks’ rent for tenant damage including pets, £50,000 of eviction costs and three months’ rent during remedial works, with Centurion running the legal process. Tenants must meet the Minimum Reference Criteria; the referencing can be done by any party. It can start mid-tenancy, with a 90-day exclusion for claims.
- Protecting Tenancies (paid by the tenant) is Centurion acting as professional guarantor, with 24 months’ rent and 10 weeks’ damage cover. If your tenants don’t meet the Minimum Reference Criteria, ask them to take this instead.
Questions to ask any provider
- Does the tenant have to pass referencing, and against what criteria?
- Is damage covered, and up to how much?
- Who runs the eviction, and is there a cap on legal costs?
- How quickly are claims paid, and is there an excess?
- Does my existing insurer accept a professional guarantor alongside its policy? Some don’t, so check before combining them.
FAQs
Can I have both?
Yes, but check each set of terms so they don’t conflict.
Is a professional guarantor insurance?
No. It is a contractual guarantee given by a company, not an insurance policy.
Who chases the tenant if rent stops?
With Centurion, Centurion pays you and pursues the tenant for repayment.
Can I add cover to an existing tenancy?
Protecting Landlords can be taken out mid-tenancy; claims are excluded for the first 90 days.
Does it work for portfolios?
Yes. Protecting Landlords is available per property or on a portfolio basis.